Someone trying to make sense of their distress may already feel obliged to explain it. What happened? When did it begin? Why does it still matter? Television adds another possible demand: that the explanation should be compelling, with a recognisable cause and a moment when everything finally falls into place.
The Friday Times has raised concerns about the romanticisation of trauma in television drama. The headline alone cannot tell us which portrayals its argument addresses, but the concern invites a useful distinction. Giving suffering a place in a story can make it visible. Making suffering serve the story can distort what we expect of the person experiencing it.
Drama needs selection. Years become episodes; uncertainty becomes a revelation. There is nothing inherently dishonest about that. Fiction can approach experiences that ordinary conversation struggles to accommodate, and insisting that every drama behave like a clinical case report would leave us with some remarkably dull evenings.
The difficulty begins when narrative satisfaction becomes an expectation we bring to real people.
A painful history can help us understand someone without explaining everything about them. If every choice is interpreted through that history, even sympathetically, the person has little room left to surprise us. Their anger becomes evidence, their silence becomes evidence, and disagreement with our interpretation may become further evidence. An explanation that cannot be questioned starts to look rather like a trap.
For therapeutic practice, the ethical question is whether we are listening for what the person is trying to communicate or for the story we already know how to tell. A label or technique may offer a way to approach something difficult. It does not give the practitioner ownership of its meaning. Nor should someone have to produce a dramatic account of their past to make their present difficulty worth taking seriously.
There is a similar responsibility in everyday life. We can resist asking suffering to justify itself through exceptional depth, insight or eventual transformation. A person may want to understand what happened. They may also want to sleep, manage an ordinary afternoon, or speak about something else for a while.
Those wishes deserve attention, even when they would make a poor final episode.