Someone speaking about their mental health or addiction has a reasonable claim on our attention. They should not have to make themselves sufficiently sympathetic before we become willing to listen. Yet sympathy can be a surprisingly conditional thing, particularly when suffering includes behaviour we find difficult, frightening or exhausting.
Brock University has reported on a psychology graduate seeking to challenge stigma around mental health and addiction. The ambition deserves consideration beyond the familiar call for greater awareness. What, exactly, are we asking people to become aware of? A category of difficulty, or the person whose life cannot be adequately described by that category?
There is a practical difference. We can learn the preferred terminology and still approach someone as though their diagnosis has answered every important question about them. We might become more polite without becoming any more curious.
For therapeutic practice, this is a professional concern. A label may help organise an assessment or communicate a concern. It should remain open to examination alongside what the person actually says. If every disagreement becomes evidence of their condition, the practitioner has created a closed argument. The person can speak, but cannot meaningfully correct the account being made of them.
There is an obvious complication here. Taking suffering seriously does not require us to excuse harmful behaviour, abandon boundaries or pretend that expertise has no value. Families, colleagues and practitioners may have legitimate concerns which deserve a hearing too. Challenging stigma becomes less convincing if it asks everyone else to suppress what has happened to them.
The harder task is to keep judgement specific. A harmful action can be addressed without treating it as a complete account of the person responsible. A diagnosis can inform care without acquiring authority over everything that person thinks or wants.
For anyone offering therapeutic help, that leaves an uncomfortable obligation: to notice when an explanation has become too convenient. When did we last revise it? What could the person tell us that would change our understanding?
Those questions belong inside the work. Public messages about acceptance have limited value if, once the consultation begins, the person discovers that everything about them has already been decided.