By the time someone asks a therapist for help, they may already have found an explanation for their suffering. Perhaps a name for it, too. Giving up that explanation can feel like losing the first thing that has made their experience bearable, even when it does not quite fit.
That possibility deserves attention as AI enters the conversations people have about themselves.
A report carried by Markets Insider attributes to psychotherapist and Limitless Executive Solutions founder Nick Jonsson the claim that 65% of new clients seeking help with emotional difficulties and addiction had already turned to AI. The supplied reporting does not establish the sample size, what those conversations involved or whether people found them helpful. It cannot tell us how widespread this is beyond the clients described.
It does, however, invite a practical question: what should a therapist do with an explanation that was formed before the person entered the room?
Simply dismissing it because it came from AI would be a poor beginning. Someone may have used a private conversation with a machine to attempt words they could not yet say to another person. Whatever the limitations of the response, that attempt matters. Asking what they were trying to understand may reveal more than immediately correcting the answer they received.
Yet accepting the explanation unexamined creates another problem. A coherent account can become a constraint. Once someone has a label, they may begin selecting the parts of their experience that support it, leaving awkward details outside the story. This possibility is hardly confined to AI. Human professionals also need to examine the appeal of their preferred explanations.
The responsibility, then, is to make an explanation discussable without making the person feel foolish for having needed it.
That requires more than asking whether an AI answer was accurate. What did it allow the person to express? What did it leave unexplored? Can they disagree with it, or has it acquired an authority they feel unable to question?
There is a complication here for practitioners who want people to arrive ready to challenge everything except the practitioner’s own account. The same scrutiny must apply in the room.
If someone arrives with a convincing story about themselves, therapy needs room for the detail that refuses to fit. Including the detail that unsettles the therapist’s explanation as much as the machine’s.