THE MANIFESTATION PARADOX · Discover a different approach to manifestation THE MANIFESTATION PARADOX Explore the trainingExplore the training
Article

A Diagnosis Cannot Decide Who Gets a Voice

November 1, 2026

Someone may need help with parts of daily life and still have a view about the society they want to live in. The difficulty begins when their need for help becomes the explanation for everything about them, including whether their views deserve to count.

Psychology Today has raised the question of who decides whether someone is mentally capable of voting. The supplied reporting does not establish a particular case or legal ruling, so neither should be assumed. But the question itself exposes a serious problem: how easily an assessment of a person can become authority over that person.

There is a distinction worth holding onto here. A diagnosis describes something relevant to someone’s condition. Whether they can understand and make a particular decision requires a more specific enquiry. Moving from one to the other without examining that decision allows a label to do work it cannot justify by itself.

Voting makes this especially uncomfortable. What understanding would be sufficient? An account of every policy? An ability to explain the electoral system? Plenty of people would struggle with either. If someone’s mental health or cognitive difficulties invite scrutiny, the standard must not quietly become more demanding than the one applied to everybody else.

There is a genuine complication, though. Concern about exclusion cannot settle what to do when someone cannot express a choice, or when another person may be directing it. Calling every intervention oppressive would leave that problem untouched. Support can enable a person’s wishes to be heard; it can also provide cover for substituting somebody else’s wishes. The difference matters, even when it is difficult to establish.

For therapeutic practice, this invites some restraint about the reach of professional judgement. Knowing something about a person’s suffering does not confer knowledge of everything they can understand, value or decide. Any opinion carrying consequences for their participation should make its limits visible: what has actually been assessed, what help was available, and what remains unknown.

Before asking who is qualified to take a decision away, there is an earlier task: establish whether the person could make it with appropriate support. Otherwise, we risk treating the absence of help as evidence of the absence of ability.