THE MANIFESTATION PARADOX · Discover a different approach to manifestation THE MANIFESTATION PARADOX Explore the trainingExplore the training
Article

Therapy Must Leave Room for What It Cannot Explain

November 5, 2026

A person receiving therapeutic help should still be allowed to make something that their therapist does not understand. A drawing, a piece of writing, an imagined scene: these need not immediately become evidence of a condition or material for the next intervention. There is a particular pressure in being continually interpreted. Eventually, even your own creations may seem to belong to somebody else’s account of you.

A reported conference listing from Friedrich Schiller University Jena brings Jean Oury, institutional psychotherapy and the “resistance of art” together under the title *Reconsidering the Imaginary*. The available report does not establish what speakers argued or what emerged from the event. Its subject nevertheless opens a worthwhile inquiry for therapeutic practice: what happens when the wish to understand someone leaves too little room for what remains unfamiliar?

Understanding is part of the work. Practitioners need to notice, ask, assess and sometimes act. Refusing interpretation altogether would hardly be a responsible answer, particularly where someone is suffering or at risk. Nor should art be romanticised as an expression beyond question, as though anything made imaginatively must therefore be beneficial.

The difficulty lies in deciding whose understanding takes precedence, and how quickly.

Suppose someone brings a drawing into a session. Asking what it means to them leaves several possibilities open, including that they do not know, or would rather talk about how they made it. Explaining what it reveals can close those possibilities before they have been explored. Even a plausible interpretation deserves some restraint when the practitioner’s position gives it more authority than the person’s own uncertainty.

This matters for any practice that uses imagination. Permission to work with someone’s inner life is not ownership of its meaning. A technique may help organise the work; it cannot settle in advance what every image signifies.

There is also a practical consequence here. When a person disagrees with an interpretation, that disagreement needs somewhere to go other than into another interpretation. Otherwise, the practitioner has built an account that cannot be corrected by the very person it concerns.

Before asking how an imaginative expression can be used therapeutically, there is room for a less ambitious question: does its maker want it used that way at all?