Someone trying to feel better can turn even a modest piece of advice into another obligation. Now there is something else to remember, something else to get right. If happiness does not follow, the temptation may be to ask what is wrong with them.
That possibility deserves attention whenever therapeutic advice is offered to everybody.
Upworthy has reported a psychotherapist’s recommendation of a single, research-based habit for happiness. Its headline presents the recommendation as something everyone should adopt. The supplied reporting does not identify the habit or the research behind it, so there is no responsible basis here for judging either. What can be examined is the reach of that word, “everyone”.
There is a considerable distance between evidence that a practice can help and a recommendation that every person ought to follow it. Crossing that distance requires attention to circumstances, to what the research actually examined, and to what the person receiving the advice wants help with. The phrase “research-based” cannot do all that work by itself.
Of course, accessible advice has a place. It would be absurd to insist that nobody could offer a useful suggestion without first conducting a full assessment. A small, manageable change may be precisely what someone is looking for. Making everything complicated can become its own kind of unhelpfulness.
The difficulty begins when a suggestion acquires the authority of a requirement.
For therapeutic practice, the consequence is practical. A person should be able to say that a recommendation did not help without having that response treated as evidence of insufficient effort or unwillingness to change. Their response is information. It belongs in the conversation.
Happiness itself also needs a little room. Someone living through loss may have priorities that cannot sensibly be reduced to feeling happier. Advice can still be offered, but it should leave them free to decide whether that is the task before them.
A practitioner recommending a habit has a further responsibility: to remain interested in what happens when this particular person tries it, including the possibility that they would be better served by something else.