Someone loses money to a scam, and the judgement often arrives before the details: how could they have believed it? Behind that question sits a comfortable assumption that we would have recognised the deception. We know what we are like. We are sensible.
Yet how much does that confidence allow for the state we happen to be in?
Everyday Health reports that losing even an hour of sleep could increase vulnerability to scams. The headline alone does not establish how the research was conducted, how large any effect was, or how widely it applies. It would be premature to turn it into a precise rule about an individual’s judgement. It does, however, offer a useful challenge to the way we interpret a mistake.
We readily turn an action into an identity. A person believed something false, so they are gullible. They acted hastily, so they are irresponsible. Once the label is in place, curiosity tends to stop. The person may then have to contend with both the original loss and a description of themselves that seems to explain everything.
For therapeutic practice, there is a responsibility here. An explanation should remain open long enough to consider the circumstances in which someone acted. Asking about sleep need not mean reducing a painful experience to tiredness. Equally, there is little sense in searching for a deep psychological explanation while leaving ordinary conditions unexplored.
There is a complication. If every mistake is attributed to circumstances, we risk leaving people with no useful sense of agency. Someone who has been deceived may want to understand what they can do differently. Reassuring them that nothing was their fault can close that conversation as effectively as blaming them.
A more useful discussion makes room for practical choices without demanding a verdict on character. Where a decision can wait, postponing it until after rest is an option worth considering. So is asking another person to look at it. Neither requires someone to declare themselves incapable.
The scammer remains responsible for the deception. The person deceived still deserves help examining what happened, without being required to accept “gullible” as their name.