For someone seeking help, a celebrated therapy can carry an uncomfortable promise. If it has helped so many people, surely it ought to help them. When it does not, disappointment can become something more corrosive: perhaps they have misunderstood, resisted, or somehow failed at getting better.
That possibility deserves a place in any conversation about therapeutic achievement.
The gratitude expressed towards Dr Linehan in a Psychology Today headline invites reflection on how a profession honours influential figures. There is nothing inherently suspect about gratitude. People whose work changes what help is available deserve recognition. But admiration becomes less useful when it makes a therapeutic approach difficult to question, especially for the person sitting opposite the practitioner.
A method acquires authority through its reputation. The person arriving for help may have very little authority at all, at least in their own estimation. They may already be accustomed to having their account of themselves corrected. In that encounter, even a well-intentioned explanation can close a door: the approach is sound; the difficulty must lie in how the person is engaging with it.
Sometimes engagement genuinely is difficult. Practitioners need room to recognise avoidance, uncertainty and the considerable effort that change can involve. Simply abandoning an approach whenever someone struggles would be another way of letting them down.
Yet persistence needs scrutiny too. What would persuade the practitioner that their understanding was incomplete? Can the person disagree without having that disagreement absorbed into an explanation of what is wrong with them?
These are practical questions about who gets heard when treatment is not going as hoped. They matter wherever a named approach becomes closely bound to professional identity.
Perhaps the most demanding way to honour a contribution is to keep its application open to examination. That includes making space for accounts which do not fit the success story.
Someone who says, “This is not helping me,” has given the practitioner information. Before explaining it away, there needs to be enough room in the relationship to find out what it means.