You are on the edge of sleep when your body suddenly jolts. The interruption is physical, but the next part may be a question: what was that? And, perhaps more troublingly, what does it say about me?
There is a considerable distance between those two questions. Therapeutic practice needs to respect it.
A VICE report addresses the bodily jolt that can occur just before sleep, with a headline promising its “real reason”. The headline alone does not establish an explanation, and it would be irresponsible to supply one on its behalf. It does, however, offer a useful starting point for considering our appetite for explanations, particularly when our own bodies surprise us.
An unexplained sensation leaves room for interpretation. Someone already worried about their wellbeing might understand it as evidence that something is wrong. A practitioner might be tempted to fit it into a familiar account of stress, emotional difficulty or unresolved experience. An explanation can feel persuasive simply because it gives the experience somewhere to belong.
That is where professional restraint matters. A person’s distress deserves attention; the explanation attached to it still needs examining. Taking someone seriously includes being willing to leave part of their experience unexplained.
There is an objection here. Surely understanding can relieve fear? Certainly an accurate explanation may help. But reassurance and accuracy are separate responsibilities. A confident account that briefly settles someone can also leave them watching for the next sensation, ready to read it through the story they have been given.
For practitioners, the consequence is practical. Ask what happened, what the person understood it to mean, and how that understanding is affecting them. Keep those enquiries distinct. Where medical assessment is appropriate, a psychological interpretation should not become an obstacle to it.
Sleep is already an awkward activity to supervise. Adding a demand to decipher every bodily interruption risks making bedtime another examination of whether we are functioning correctly. We should be careful about giving people more to monitor when they came looking for help to rest.