GDAŃSK, POLAND · 14–19 JUNE 2027 · Six days of live Sanomentology practitioner training GDAŃSK, POLAND 2027 · LIVE PRACTITIONER TRAINING Explore the trainingGdańsk 2027 · Book Live Training
Article

A Diagnosis Must Leave Room for the Person to Disagree

November 3, 2026

Once someone has been told that anxiety explains what they are experiencing, what happens when they remain convinced that something is wrong? They may now have two difficulties: the original concern, and the need to persuade someone that their concern is not further evidence of anxiety.

That is a difficult position to put a person in. It deserves attention wherever people seek help, including therapeutic practice.

BBC Health reports that Beth Jenkins was initially told she had anxiety before being diagnosed with breast cancer, and that she had been told she was too young to have the disease. The supplied account does not establish the full clinical sequence or what information was available at each consultation. It cannot support a verdict on every decision made. It does, however, give us reason to examine what happens when an explanation becomes difficult to question.

Labels can be useful. Naming a problem may bring relief, make treatment possible and give someone language for an experience they could barely describe. Yet a label also directs attention. Once it is in place, there is a temptation to hear everything through it, including the person’s objections.

For a therapist, this is a particular responsibility. Psychological understanding can become surprisingly expansive. There is always another interpretation available: fear, resistance, avoidance. Unless the practitioner recognises the limits of that interpretative freedom, disagreement itself can be absorbed into the explanation. The person is left with no answer that could count against it.

Of course, taking someone seriously cannot mean accepting every feared diagnosis as correct. Anxiety deserves proper attention in its own right, and no professional can promise certainty. The difficulty is to preserve judgement without making professional authority immune to correction.

In practice, that requires room for an unfinished answer. A therapist need not know what a physical symptom means to recognise that its explanation may fall outside their competence. Nor should an existing psychological diagnosis settle every subsequent concern.

The practical test is what happens when someone returns and says, “This still does not make sense to me.” Can the explanation be reconsidered? Can another professional be involved? Can the person disagree without their disagreement being made into a symptom?

Those are questions a practitioner needs to answer before asking someone else to trust them.