GDAŃSK, POLAND · 14–19 JUNE 2027 · Six days of live Sanomentology practitioner training GDAŃSK, POLAND 2027 · LIVE PRACTITIONER TRAINING Explore the trainingGdańsk 2027 · Book Live Training
Article

A Theory of Consciousness Cannot Tell Us Who Is Trying

October 29, 2026

When someone struggles to engage in a conversation about their distress, the temptation is to explain the difficulty through character. They are unwilling to change. They are avoiding something. They are not doing the work. Each explanation may sound plausible, particularly to the person whose work is apparently being resisted. Plausibility is a poor substitute for knowing.

A report from Bioengineer.org describes a new framework that puts brain metabolism closer to the centre of questions about consciousness. The headline alone does not establish what the framework explains, how it has been tested or whether its proposals will survive scrutiny. It does, however, invite a useful disturbance: how much do our accounts of mental life leave out when we concentrate on what a person thinks and says?

For therapeutic practice, the immediate consequence should be greater care in interpretation. A theory about the biological conditions of consciousness cannot tell a practitioner why a particular person has gone quiet, failed to complete an agreed task or found an apparently simple decision overwhelming. It certainly cannot turn those observations into evidence of unwillingness.

There is an opposite temptation, too. Introduce a biological explanation and everything can begin to look settled. The person becomes a mechanism; meaning becomes an incidental detail. Yet even a successful account of how conscious experience is sustained would leave the practitioner needing to understand what that experience is like for the person having it. Explaining its conditions would not settle its significance.

The practical responsibility sits in that unresolved space. Practitioners need to examine the demands they make, including the demand that someone should be able to explain themselves clearly before their difficulty is taken seriously. An interpretation should remain open to correction, especially when it conveniently locates the problem entirely within the client.

None of this establishes a new treatment, validates a technique or gives anyone permission to make claims about changing brain metabolism. The reported framework is an invitation to investigate, not a clinical licence.

For now, there is a smaller discipline available: when a person cannot do what has been asked of them, pause before deciding what that says about their willingness. The explanation may be less complete than the professional vocabulary makes it sound.