There is a particular risk in being given an explanation for yourself: other people may decide that the explaining is finished. Something you say, something you struggle with, even your disagreement with their interpretation can then be folded back into the explanation. You are present in the conversation, yet somehow no longer needed.
Psychology Today has published a piece calling for a change in how ADHD is understood. The supplied headline does not establish what change the author proposes. It does, however, offer a useful starting point for examining the responsibility that comes with describing another person.
A diagnosis can provide a language in which someone can ask for help. It should also remain possible for them to say, “That does not describe what is happening to me here,” without having their account treated as less credible simply because a diagnosis exists.
This matters in therapeutic practice. Once a practitioner has an explanation in mind, there is a temptation to hear confirmation everywhere. The explanation becomes efficient. Questions become narrower. The person’s own account starts to sound like supplementary material.
Yet an appointment concerns someone’s particular difficulty, in a particular life. What are they asking for help with? What do they want to be able to do? Which parts of the explanation make sense to them, and where does it leave something important unexplained? Those questions still require answers.
There is an objection worth taking seriously. Talk about the limits of labels can itself become dismissive. Someone seeking recognition of a persistent difficulty does not need a philosophical lecture about being more than their diagnosis. They may need practical support, careful assessment or appropriate treatment. Being seen as an individual should never become an excuse for withholding these.
The professional task therefore involves a continuing discipline: use the diagnosis where it helps, and notice when it begins to answer questions that have not actually been asked.
Before adopting a new way of understanding ADHD, it is worth examining how the existing understanding is being used in the room. If a person cannot correct the practitioner’s interpretation, changing the terminology may leave the most consequential problem untouched.