There is a particular burden in being asked to explain your suffering when you cannot explain it to yourself. A person seeking help for depression may already be searching for the mistake they made, the thought they ought to change, the reason they cannot simply get on with things. The practitioner’s explanation can ease that burden. It can also give it a new shape.
Everyday Health reports on a study suggesting that body-clock difficulties may contribute to what it calls ‘circadian’ depression. The supplied report does not establish how the researchers reached that conclusion or what it means for treatment. It offers a possibility worth examining, rather than grounds for telling someone why they are depressed.
That distinction matters in therapeutic work. Once an explanation becomes available, there is a temptation to make the person fit it. A psychological interpretation can do this just as readily as a biological one. We can become so interested in what makes sense within our preferred approach that the person’s account starts to seem like supporting material.
A possible contribution from the body clock challenges any assumption that suffering must yield its meaning through conversation alone. Yet replacing an exclusively psychological account with an exclusively biological one would leave much of the same problem intact. Knowing something about a mechanism does not tell us what it is like to live with its consequences, or what else is happening in that life.
There is an objection here: people need explanations, and practitioners need some basis for acting. Endless openness can become an elegant way of doing very little.
The answer is to keep an explanation available for revision. In practice, that means being clear about what a report actually supports, recognising the boundaries of one’s competence, and resisting the urge to turn an emerging finding into a promise about a technique.
For Sanomentology practitioners, this is a useful point of scrutiny. Can a person bring information that unsettles the explanation being offered? Can they say that something does not fit without their disagreement itself becoming a symptom to interpret?
A practitioner needs enough confidence to work, and enough restraint to let the account change. The person seeking help should not have to defend their experience against the very explanation intended to help them.