A child who has lost a parent should not also have to become exceptionally good at enduring hardship. Yet there is an uncomfortable possibility within the language of resilience: adults may begin to admire a child’s capacity to cope before asking how much that child is being required to carry.
Rising Kashmir reports on orphans in Jammu and Kashmir facing trauma and poverty. The supplied headline offers no basis for judging individual circumstances or the support available to particular children. It does, however, bring two kinds of need into the same frame, where they belong. Any serious consideration of psychological care has to keep them there.
For a practitioner, the danger is that suffering becomes most visible in the form the profession knows how to address. Fear, grief and distress enter the consultation; the material conditions surrounding them can slip into the background, treated as context. But context is a rather bloodless word for the circumstances in which a child must actually live.
This does not make therapeutic work pointless while hardship continues. That would be another way of withholding help. A child should not have to wait for every external problem to be resolved before receiving thoughtful psychological support. Equally, a practitioner needs to be honest about the reach of that support. An improvement in how someone manages distress cannot, by itself, tell us whether their circumstances have become acceptable.
There is a question here about what we count as success. If adults value composure too highly, the quieter child may reassure everyone without having less to bear. Nor should visible distress become the price of being taken seriously. Neither response gives us permission to stop attending to the child’s actual needs.
Professional responsibility includes recognising when a need exceeds the service being offered, and taking that limit seriously. Where material hardship is reported alongside psychological suffering, care must leave room for practical assistance and the responsibilities of other adults and institutions.
The temptation is to make the child’s inner world the place where an intolerable situation gets resolved. It is a convenient place for adults to locate the work. The child is already doing enough.