A student can struggle to ask for help because asking feels like an admission that they should never have been admitted. A university can make that struggle worse without anyone intending harm. It need only assume that everyone already knows how the place works.
This is a possibility worth keeping in mind when psychology turns its attention to students themselves. How readily might we describe someone’s anxiety while leaving the conditions provoking it largely unexamined?
The University of Nevada, Reno reports that KC De la Rosa is contributing to psychology research and supporting first-generation students. The supplied account does not establish what that support involves or what it has achieved. It does, however, bring two responsibilities into view: developing knowledge about human beings and making it possible for more people to participate in that work.
There is an important connection here. Someone entering an unfamiliar institution may have to learn both the subject and the unwritten arrangements surrounding it. Who can be approached? Which questions are acceptable? What does everyone else appear to understand without having been told?
If that uncertainty is understood solely as a problem of confidence, support can become rather peculiar. We teach the person to feel more comfortable navigating something we have made unnecessarily difficult to navigate.
The therapeutic parallel deserves care. A practitioner cannot assume that distress is explained by someone’s circumstances, any more than they can assume it originates entirely within the individual. Both shortcuts spare the professional some difficult thinking. Neither gives the person much room to be particular.
Nor should “first-generation” become a ready-made psychological description. It identifies something about educational background; it cannot tell us how a particular student feels, what they need, or whether they want assistance at all.
The practical consequence is demanding. Before deciding that someone needs greater resilience, confidence or motivation, examine what they are being asked to manage. Some difficulties call for personal support. Others require a clearer explanation, a different arrangement, or someone with authority taking responsibility for an avoidable obstacle.
Psychology should be able to distinguish between those possibilities. Otherwise, becoming better at helping people cope can leave us strangely incurious about what they are coping with.