GDAŃSK, POLAND · 14–19 JUNE 2027 · Six days of live Sanomentology practitioner training GDAŃSK, POLAND 2027 · LIVE PRACTITIONER TRAINING Explore the trainingGdańsk 2027 · Book Live Training
Article

Question the Treatment Without Taking Away the Person’s Voice

October 26, 2026

Someone sitting opposite a practitioner may want an explanation for what is happening to them. They may also be afraid of what an explanation will do: whether it will help them understand their life or become the description through which everything they say is subsequently heard.

That is a difficult responsibility to place in anyone’s hands.

Psychology Today’s recent framing of psychiatry as both under scrutiny and facing a choice of direction invites a question about therapeutic authority. The headline alone does not establish the particulars of that debate. It does, however, offer a starting point: how can a profession examine its own explanations while continuing to help people who cannot simply put their suffering on hold?

A diagnosis can be useful without answering every important question about the person receiving it. Equally, questioning a diagnosis does not establish that an alternative explanation is better. There is a temptation, when challenging an established profession, to give its challengers rather more freedom than we would give the profession itself. An unfamiliar vocabulary can sound liberating. It still needs examining.

For anyone working therapeutically, including within Sanomentology, this is an uncomfortable but necessary demand. If we ask whether psychiatric language leaves enough room for the individual, we must ask the same of our own language. Can the person disagree with our interpretation without that disagreement becoming further evidence that we are right?

Otherwise, an explanation can become impossible to challenge from the very position it claims to explain.

There is a complication here. Practitioners need judgement; they cannot make every decision conditional on agreement. Taking someone seriously does not require accepting every account unquestioningly. But professional judgement should remain open to correction, particularly when the person’s account does not fit the preferred explanation.

The practical consequence is demanding. When treatment appears unsuccessful, the enquiry must include the treatment, the interpretation and the practitioner’s assumptions. It cannot settle automatically on something deficient in the person seeking help.

Criticism of psychiatry earns its usefulness when it makes that examination more possible. Replacing one unquestionable explanation with another leaves the person in much the same chair.