Someone seeking therapy may already be struggling to explain what hurts. If they must also establish that their identity deserves a fair hearing, the work has acquired another burden before it has properly begun.
The St. Louis Jewish Light reports that some Jewish patients seeking therapy say they have encountered antisemitism instead. The supplied reporting does not establish the circumstances of individual encounters, so it would be wrong to pronounce on particular practitioners or assume that every disputed exchange had the same meaning. The concern nevertheless deserves serious attention: what happens when the person entrusted with helping someone understand their suffering becomes another person before whom they feel obliged to defend themselves?
A therapist has considerable influence over how an encounter is understood. They can describe a response as avoidance, defensiveness or resistance. Those descriptions may sometimes be useful. But a professional vocabulary can also make it remarkably easy to explain away an objection without examining what prompted it. A patient who says, “You have misunderstood me,” might be identifying something the practitioner needs to hear.
This is particularly important where identity enters the room. Jewish identity cannot reasonably be treated as evidence of a particular political position. Nor should a patient have to account for the actions of others before their own fear, grief or confusion receives attention. However strongly a practitioner feels about public events, the person seeking help is not a representative summoned to answer for them.
There is a complication here. Therapy cannot promise freedom from every uncomfortable question, and feeling challenged does not, by itself, establish prejudice. Honest exploration sometimes unsettles us. Yet that distinction cannot simply be left to the practitioner to declare. Professional responsibility includes being willing to examine whether a challenge arose from the patient’s needs or from assumptions the practitioner brought with them.
For therapeutic practice, this places a limit on confidence in any model or technique. An apparently skilful intervention can still rest on a careless understanding of the person receiving it.
When a patient reports prejudice, the practitioner’s interpretation of the encounter must itself be open to scrutiny. Otherwise, the same authority that is meant to help someone speak can become the reason they stop.