THE MANIFESTATION PARADOX · Discover a different approach to manifestation THE MANIFESTATION PARADOX Explore the trainingExplore the training
Article

Therapy Must Leave Room for the Person Who Says No

October 30, 2026

A young person offered a climbing session as part of treatment may welcome the chance to do something other than talk. Another may dread being watched while attempting something unfamiliar. The same invitation can feel like an opening or another occasion to disappoint an adult.

That difference deserves a place in how we think about therapeutic innovation.

Bioengineer.org reports that a trial will test a bouldering programme for adolescents with depression. This is a proposal to investigate a treatment, not evidence that it works. The supplied reporting does not establish outcomes or give enough detail to judge the programme itself.

Still, the prospect invites a useful examination of what happens when an activity becomes therapy. Climbing has an immediately visible task. There is something to attempt, and progress that someone else can see. That makes it tempting to reach for a metaphor: overcoming obstacles, finding a foothold, getting further than you thought possible. The metaphor practically writes the publicity.

A person’s suffering is less obliging.

Reaching a hold cannot, by itself, tell us whether someone is less depressed. Refusing to climb cannot tell us that they are unwilling to get better. Once practitioners invest an activity with therapeutic significance, they have a responsibility to avoid reading more into participation than it can bear.

There is an objection here. Any treatment asks something of the person receiving it, and unfamiliarity is not necessarily a reason to stop. A young person might discover value in something they would never have chosen unaided. Respecting choice need not mean withdrawing every invitation at the first hesitation.

The distinction lies in whether hesitation can be explored without becoming evidence against the person. Can they dislike climbing without being described as resistant? Can they enjoy it without having their enjoyment turned into a claim of recovery?

Research can examine whether a programme helps. Therapeutic practice must also attend to what happens around that question, including the expectations carried into the room by adults who very much want it to help.

An adolescent should not have to protect a practitioner’s enthusiasm. Whatever the trial eventually finds, the young person who says, “This isn’t for me,” is providing information worth hearing. The next task is to find out what they mean, rather than explain their answer away.